WHP Logo

The White Horse Press

Environmental Values

Contents of Volume 13

Other volumes of EV

Environmental Values

Reproductive Liberty and Overpopulation: A Response

Stanley Warner

Environmental Values 13(2004): 393-399. doi: 10.3197/096327104323312743

This appraisal of Carol A. Kates' 'Reproductive Liberty and Overpopulation' challenges her call for world-wide population control measures - using compulsory methods if necessary - to save the world's environment. The most successful part of Kates' paper is her argument that reproductive rights are not indefeasible and nonnegotiable, but that like many rights, they are conditional and open to a balancing of individual freedom against collective community interests. But her advocacy of mandatory state population controls is flawed in several respects. First, she underestimates the force of the emerging consensus for voluntary population reductions through policies that empower women. Second, she walks on difficult ethical grounds. Are compulsory controls on reproduction ethically justified simply because humans are loathe to take the alternative route of curtailing their 'individualistic' 'materialistic' appetites for more economic growth and consumption? Third, Kates fails to recognise that her search for measures that immediately and directly reverse population growth would necessitate coercing an entire generation of women toward zero reproduction in order for death rates to have their effect. Lastly, problems with the feasibility of her plan and the absence of international support make it unlikely it will ever come to pass. Alternatives to Kates' policies are discussed at the close.

KEYWORDS: Population control, reproductive rights, environmental justice, Carol Kates

REFERENCES to other articles in Environmental Values:

Reproductive Liberty and Overpopulation. Carol A. Kates

Global Population Growth and the Demise of Nature. Stanley Warner, Mark Feinstein, Raymond Coppinger and Elisabeth Clemence CITATIONS in other Environmental Values articles:

Reproductive Liberty and Overpopulation. Carol A. Kates

Reproductive Liberty and Overpopulation: Reply to Stanley Warner. Carol A. Kates

This article is available online (PDF format) from Ingenta Journals. Access is free if your institution subscribes to Environmental Values. Reprints of this article can be ordered from ingenta or the British Library

Contact the publishers for subscriptions and back numbers of Environmental Values.

The Old Vicarage, Winwick
Cambridgeshire, PE28 5PN, UK
Tel: +44 1832 293222